Opened in 2013, after the 10-year anniversary of the league, the BJHL Hall of Fame commemorates the best players in the history of the Bench Jockey Hardball League.

Every season, the Commissioner's Office selects a handful of players for consideration. To be selected, a player must have had a minimum of 10 years spent in the BJHL (not counting any time spent in the minor or international leagues), and must have accumulated statistics and renown that the Commissioner believes warrants Hall of Fame consideration. The league's owners then vote on the candidates. For a player to enter the Hall of Fame, his name must appear on two-thirds of the ballots submitted that season. Any player not receiving that many votes will automatically be placed on the ballot again the following season, for a maximum of five seasons. Should a player be named by less than 10% of the voters in any given year, however, he is permanently disqualified from Hall of Fame nomination. The owners are not directed to consider any specific criteria when submitting their votes: everyone is free to decide for themselves what constitutes a worthy career and what does not.

It is worth noting that many of the players selected to the Hall in early seasons had an abbreviated career due to their age at the league's inception in 2003, and thus never had the opportunity to accumulate the same calibre of statistics as the players selected in later years. So even though they may appear to be of a lesser pedigree than later-day players, they are given places of equal honour in this Hall.

All the current Hall of Famers are listed below by induction year. Each list is also a link that will take you to a page containing more details about the player(s) inducted that year. For every player, you will find a plaque identifying their name, position, years of service in the BJHL, and the team with which they had the greatest success. Beside each plaque is a summary of the player's career highlights. The plaques themselves are links to each player's SION page, which lists biographical data and career statistics.